[PATCH 4 of 5] d50 aggregation by median instead of arithmetic mean,

Wald Commits scm-commit at wald.intevation.org
Thu Mar 1 09:12:17 CET 2018


# HG changeset patch
# User mschaefer
# Date 1519891318 -3600
# Node ID 29442c03c6e3fa205ac663714868dea604502b2e
# Parent  5d5d0051723fec488b7df6bfefba86c0a5bc7931
d50 aggregation by median instead of arithmetic mean,
negative tkh replaced by 0

diff -r 5d5d0051723f -r 29442c03c6e3 artifacts/src/main/java/org/dive4elements/river/artifacts/sinfo/tkhcalculation/BedQualityD50KmValueFinder.java
--- a/artifacts/src/main/java/org/dive4elements/river/artifacts/sinfo/tkhcalculation/BedQualityD50KmValueFinder.java	Wed Feb 28 18:55:39 2018 +0100
+++ b/artifacts/src/main/java/org/dive4elements/river/artifacts/sinfo/tkhcalculation/BedQualityD50KmValueFinder.java	Thu Mar 01 09:01:58 2018 +0100
@@ -19,12 +19,15 @@
 import org.apache.commons.math.analysis.interpolation.LinearInterpolator;
 import org.apache.commons.math.analysis.polynomials.PolynomialSplineFunction;
 import org.apache.log4j.Logger;
+import org.dive4elements.river.artifacts.math.Utils;
 import org.dive4elements.river.backend.SedDBSessionHolder;
 import org.dive4elements.river.model.River;
 import org.hibernate.SQLQuery;
 import org.hibernate.Session;
 import org.hibernate.type.StandardBasicTypes;
 
+import gnu.trove.TDoubleArrayList;
+
 /**
  * Searchable sorted km array with parallel bed measurements value array and linear interpolation for km and d50 between
  * the array elements.<br />
@@ -34,116 +37,7 @@
  * @author Matthias Schäfer
  *
  */
-final class BedQualityD50KmValueFinder {
-
-    /***** INNER CLASSES *****/
-
-    /**
-     * A bed measurements aggregate with its d50 characteristic grain diameter
-     */
-    private static class D50Measurement {
-        private double km;
-
-        public double getKm() {
-            return this.km;
-        }
-
-        // private Date mindate;
-
-        // public Date getMinDate() {
-        // return this.mindate;
-        // }
-
-        // private Date maxdate;
-
-        // public Date getMaxDate() {
-        // return this.maxdate;
-        // }
-
-        private int cnt;
-
-        public int getCnt() {
-            return this.cnt;
-        }
-
-        // private double mindepth;
-
-        // public double getMinDepth() {
-        // return this.mindepth;
-        // }
-
-        // private double maxdepth;
-
-        // public double getMaxDepth() {
-        // return this.maxdepth;
-        // }
-
-        private double d50;
-
-        /**
-         * D50 in m
-         */
-        public double getD50() {
-            return this.d50;
-        }
-
-        // /**
-        // * Parameter constructor
-        // */
-        // public D50Measurement(final double km, final Date mindate, final Date maxdate, final int cnt, final double mindepth,
-        // final double maxdepth,
-        // final double d50mm) {
-        // this.km = km;
-        // this.mindate = mindate;
-        // this.maxdate = maxdate;
-        // this.cnt = cnt;
-        // this.mindepth = mindepth;
-        // this.maxdepth = maxdepth;
-        // this.d50 = d50mm / 1000;
-        // }
-
-        /**
-         * Query result row constructor
-         */
-        public D50Measurement(final Object[] tuple, final String[] aliases) {
-            this.km = 0;
-            // this.mindate = null;
-            // this.maxdate = null;
-            this.cnt = 0;
-            // this.mindepth = Double.NaN;
-            // this.maxdepth = Double.NaN;
-            this.d50 = Double.NaN;
-            for (int i = 0; i < tuple.length; ++i) {
-                if (tuple[i] == null)
-                    continue;
-                switch (aliases[i]) {
-                case "km":
-                    this.km = ((Number) tuple[i]).doubleValue();
-                    break;
-                    // case "mindate":
-                    // this.mindate = (Date) tuple[i];
-                    // break;
-                    // case "maxdate":
-                    // this.maxdate = (Date) tuple[i];
-                    // break;
-                case "cnt":
-                    this.cnt = ((Number) tuple[i]).intValue();
-                    break;
-                    // case "mindepth":
-                    // this.mindepth = ((Number) tuple[i]).doubleValue();
-                    // break;
-                    // case "maxdepth":
-                    // this.maxdepth = ((Number) tuple[i]).doubleValue();
-                    // break;
-                case "d50":
-                    this.d50 = ((Number) tuple[i]).doubleValue() / 1000; // mm to m
-                    break;
-                default:
-                    break;
-                }
-            }
-        }
-    }
+public class BedQualityD50KmValueFinder {
 
     /***** FIELDS *****/
 
@@ -153,38 +47,38 @@
     private static Logger log = Logger.getLogger(BedQualityD50KmValueFinder.class);
 
     /**
-     * Query that aggregates by km for a km range and a time period all sub layer bed measurements with their d50<br />
+     * Query selecting all sub layer bed measurements with their d50 for a km range and a time period<br />
      * <br />
      * A km may have bed measurements for multiple dates, multiple distances from the river bank, and multiple depth layers.
-     * The query filters by km range, time period and layer (sub layer: below bed to max. 50 cm depth).
-     * Those measurements are then grouped by km, and the D50 aggregated as average value.
+     * The query filters by km range, time period and layer (sub layer: below bed to max. 50 cm depth).<br />
+     * 
+     * If PostgreSQL would support a median aggregate function like Oracle does, the aggregation could be placed into this query.
      */
     private static final String SQL_BED_D50_SUBLAYER_MEASUREMENT =
-            "SELECT t.km, MIN(t.datum) AS mindate, MAX(t.datum) AS maxdate, COUNT(*) AS cnt," //
-            + " MIN(p.tiefevon) AS mindepth, MAX(p.tiefebis) AS maxdepth, AVG(a.d50) AS d50" //
-            + " FROM sohltest t INNER JOIN station s ON t.stationid = s.stationid" //
-            + "    INNER JOIN gewaesser g ON s.gewaesserid = g.gewaesserid" //
-            + "    INNER JOIN sohlprobe p ON t.sohltestid = p.sohltestid" //
-            + "    INNER JOIN siebanalyse a ON p.sohlprobeid = a.sohlprobeid" //
-            + " WHERE (g.name = :name) AND (s.km BETWEEN :fromkm - 0.0001 AND :tokm + 0.0001)" //
-            + "    AND (p.tiefevon > 0.0) AND (p.tiefebis <= 0.5)" //
-            + "    AND (t.datum BETWEEN :fromdate AND :todate)" //
-            + " GROUP BY t.km" //
-            + " ORDER BY t.km"; //
-
-    private static final String[] SQL_BED_D50_SELECT_ALIAS = { "km", "mindate", "maxdate", "cnt", "mindepth", "maxdepth", "d50" };
+    "SELECT t.km, t.datum, p.tiefevon, p.tiefebis, a.d50"
+        + " FROM sohltest t INNER JOIN station s ON t.stationid = s.stationid"
+        + "    INNER JOIN gewaesser g ON s.gewaesserid = g.gewaesserid"
+        + "    INNER JOIN sohlprobe p ON t.sohltestid = p.sohltestid"
+        + "    INNER JOIN siebanalyse a ON p.sohlprobeid = a.sohlprobeid"
+        + " WHERE (g.name = :name) AND (s.km BETWEEN :fromkm - 0.0001 AND :tokm + 0.0001)"
+        + "    AND (p.tiefevon > 0.0) AND (p.tiefebis <= 0.5)"
+        + "    AND (t.datum BETWEEN :fromdate AND :todate)"
+        + " ORDER BY t.km ASC, a.d50 ASC";
 
     /**
-     * Real linear interpolator for kms and d50 values
+     * Real linear interpolator for kms and d50 values (m)
      */
     private final PolynomialSplineFunction interpolator;
 
-    /***** METHODS *****/
 
+    /***** CONSTRUCTORS *****/
+    
     private BedQualityD50KmValueFinder(final double[] kms, final double[] values) {
         this.interpolator = new LinearInterpolator().interpolate(kms, values);
     }
 
+    /***** METHODS *****/
+    
     /**
      * Sohlbeschaffenheit (D50 Korndurchmesser aus Seddb)
      * Abhängig von Peiljahr
@@ -204,8 +98,8 @@
         log.debug(String.format("loadValues km %.3f - %.3f %tF - %tF", kmRange.getMinimumDouble(), kmRange.getMaximumDouble(), startTime, endTime));
         final Session session = SedDBSessionHolder.HOLDER.get();
         final SQLQuery sqlQuery = session.createSQLQuery(SQL_BED_D50_SUBLAYER_MEASUREMENT).addScalar("km", StandardBasicTypes.DOUBLE)
-                .addScalar("mindate", StandardBasicTypes.DATE).addScalar("maxdate", StandardBasicTypes.DATE).addScalar("cnt", StandardBasicTypes.INTEGER)
-                .addScalar("mindepth", StandardBasicTypes.DOUBLE).addScalar("maxdepth", StandardBasicTypes.DOUBLE).addScalar("d50", StandardBasicTypes.DOUBLE);
+                .addScalar("datum", StandardBasicTypes.DATE).addScalar("tiefevon", StandardBasicTypes.DOUBLE)
+                .addScalar("tiefebis", StandardBasicTypes.DOUBLE).addScalar("d50", StandardBasicTypes.DOUBLE);
         final String seddbRiver = river.nameForSeddb();
         sqlQuery.setString("name", seddbRiver);
         sqlQuery.setDouble("fromkm", kmRange.getMinimumDouble());
@@ -214,19 +108,21 @@
         sqlQuery.setDate("todate", endTime);
 
         final List<Object[]> rows = sqlQuery.list();
-        final double[] kms = new double[rows.size()];
-        final double[] values = new double[rows.size()];
-        D50Measurement measurement;
-        int i = -1;
-        for (final Object[] row : rows) {
-            measurement = new D50Measurement(row, SQL_BED_D50_SELECT_ALIAS);
-            i++;
-            kms[i] = measurement.getKm();
-            values[i] = measurement.getD50();
-            log.debug(String.format("loadValues km %.3f d50(mm) %.1f count %d", kms[i], values[i], measurement.getCnt()));
+        final TDoubleArrayList kms = new TDoubleArrayList();
+        final TDoubleArrayList values = new TDoubleArrayList();
+        final TDoubleArrayList kmd50s = new TDoubleArrayList();
+        for (int i = 0; i <= rows.size() - 1; i++) {
+            kmd50s.add((double) rows.get(i)[4]);
+            if (((i == rows.size() - 1) || !Utils.epsilonEquals((double) rows.get(i)[0], (double) rows.get(i+1)[0], 0.0001))) {
+                int k = kmd50s.size() / 2;
+                values.add(((k + k < kmd50s.size()) ? kmd50s.get(k) : (kmd50s.get(k-1) + kmd50s.get(k)) / 2) / 1000);
+                kms.add((double) rows.get(i)[0]);
+                log.debug(String.format("loadValues km %.3f d50(mm) %.1f count %d", kms.get(kms.size()-1), values.get(values.size()-1), kmd50s.size()));
+                kmd50s.clear();
+        }
         }
         try {
-            return new BedQualityD50KmValueFinder(kms, values);
+            return new BedQualityD50KmValueFinder(kms.toNativeArray(), values.toNativeArray());
         }
         catch (final Exception e) {
             e.printStackTrace();
@@ -237,7 +133,7 @@
     /**
      * Returns the d50 value interpolated according to a km
      *
-     * @return d50 (mm) of the km, or NaN
+     * @return d50 (m) of the km, or NaN
      */
     public double findD50(final double km) throws ArgumentOutsideDomainException {
         return this.interpolator.value(km);
diff -r 5d5d0051723f -r 29442c03c6e3 artifacts/src/main/java/org/dive4elements/river/artifacts/sinfo/tkhcalculation/TkhCalculator.java
--- a/artifacts/src/main/java/org/dive4elements/river/artifacts/sinfo/tkhcalculation/TkhCalculator.java	Wed Feb 28 18:55:39 2018 +0100
+++ b/artifacts/src/main/java/org/dive4elements/river/artifacts/sinfo/tkhcalculation/TkhCalculator.java	Thu Mar 01 09:01:58 2018 +0100
@@ -58,7 +58,7 @@
                 VALID_BED_MEASUREMENT_YEARS);
 
         if (bedMeasurementsFinder == null) {
-            final String message = Resources.getMsg(context.getMeta(), "sinfo_calc_flow_depth.warning.missingSoilKind", null, label);
+            final String message = Resources.getMsg(context.getMeta(), "sinfo_calc_flow_depth.warning.missingD50", null, label);
             problems.addProblem(message);
             return null;
         }
@@ -159,29 +159,13 @@
 
         if (!this.flowVelocitiesFinder.findKmQValues(km, discharge)) {
             // TODO: ggf. station in Fehlermeldung?
-            final String message = Resources.getMsg(this.context.getMeta(), "sinfo_calc_flow_depth.warning.missingQ", null, this.problemLabel);
+            final String message = Resources.getMsg(this.context.getMeta(), "sinfo_calc_flow_depth.warning.missingVelocity", null, this.problemLabel);
             this.problems.addProblem(km, message);
             // FIXME: cumulate problems to one message?
+            return new Tkh(km, wst, meanBedHeight, discharge, kind, Double.NaN, Double.NaN, Double.NaN);
         }
 
         final double tkh = calculateTkh(wst - meanBedHeight, this.flowVelocitiesFinder.getFindVmainFound(), d50, this.flowVelocitiesFinder.getFindTauFound());
-        // FIXME: noch mal prüfen, im alten code wurde hier immer auf 0 gesetzt
-        if (Double.isNaN(tkh) || (tkh < 0)) {
-            // TODO: ggf. station in Fehlermeldung?
-
-            // FIXME: Fehlermeldung nicht korrekt, passiert mit Wasserspiegel 'MHQ' und 'QP-1993
-            final String message = Resources.getMsg(this.context.getMeta(), "sinfo_calc_flow_depth.warning.missingQ", null, this.problemLabel);
-            this.problems.addProblem(km, message);
-
-            return new Tkh(km, wst, meanBedHeight, discharge, kind, Double.NaN, Double.NaN, Double.NaN);
-        }
-
-        /*
-         * log.debug(String.format("calculateTkh km %.3f q %.0f w %.2f mbh %.2f vm %.1f tau %.1f d50(mm) %.1f tkh(cm) %.1f",
-         * km, discharge, wst, meanBedHeight, flowVelocitiesFinder.getFindVmainFound(), flowVelocitiesFinder.getFindTauFound(),
-         * d50*1000, tkh));
-         */
-
         double tkhUp;
         double tkhDown;
         switch (kind) {
@@ -211,7 +195,7 @@
      *            grain diameter D50 in m (!)
      * @param tau
      *            shear stress in N/m^2
-     * @return transport body height in cm (!)
+     * @return transport body height in cm (!), never negative
      */
     private double calculateTkh(final double h, final double vm, final double d50, final double tau) {
         final double PHYS_G = 9.81;
@@ -226,6 +210,11 @@
         final double partReynolds = Math.sqrt((PHYS_SPECGRAV_S - 1) * PHYS_G * d50) / PHYS_VISCOSITY_NUE * d50;
         final double critShields = 0.22 * Math.pow(partReynolds, -0.6) + 0.06 * Math.pow(10, 7.7 * Math.pow(partReynolds, -0.6));
         final double critTau = critShields * (PHYS_GRAIN_DENSITY_RHOS - PHYS_WATER_DENSITY_RHO) * PHYS_G * d50;
-        return 100 * h * (1 - Math.pow(froude, 2)) / (2 * PHYS_VELOCCOEFF_N * PHYS_FORMCOEFF_ALPHA) * (1 - critTau / tau);
+        final double tkh = 100 * h * (1 - Math.pow(froude, 2)) / (2 * PHYS_VELOCCOEFF_N * PHYS_FORMCOEFF_ALPHA) * (1 - critTau / tau);
+        // Some regular input values may give a negative calculation result; that is unwanted
+        if (tkh < 0.0)
+            return 0.0;
+        else
+            return tkh;
     }
 }
\ No newline at end of file


More information about the Dive4Elements-commits mailing list