[Gpg4win-devel] GPGtools vs GPG4win regression

[Romain]

Hi Andre,

Thank you for your prompt reply!

> On 09 Aug 2016, at 17:10, Andre Heinecke <aheinecke at intevation.de> wrote:
> Yes this should no longer happen since 2.3.0 where we added read Support for 
> PGP MIME Mails in GpgOL. (And which we have since improved in 2.3.2) And I'm 
> pretty sure it works as I have tested this before the release and it's part of 
> our release test plan.

I attached below the headers of a problematic email.
What other information, beside screenshots, can I provide to help reproduce the issue?

We could reproduce the issue with multiple Windows 10 / Outlook 2016 clients.
The sender used the latest version of GPGTools. Disabling PGP/Mime fixed the issue on the recipient’s end.

> There is another plugin for Outlook though (Outlook Priviacy Plugin) that only 
> supports inline messages (I think, may have changed since I've looked last 
> time).
> 
> Outlook Privacy Plugin also reccomends Gpg4win to provide GnuPG and Key 
> Management for Windows, which often leads to misunderstandings. Maybe your 
> problem reporter is using that plugin?

The Outlook Privacy Plugin was not installed on the problematic hosts.

However, we have later tested that if installed, the Outlook Privacy Plugin has no problem decrypting the PGP MIME message.

Cheers,
Romain.

—
> x-pgp-agent: GPGMail
> Content-Type: multipart/mixed;
> 	boundary="_003_A37EC4D2759E46B3856D581AC3525B1Fcernch_"
> MIME-Version: 1.0
> 
> --_003_A37EC4D2759E46B3856D581AC3525B1Fcernch_
> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
> 
> 
> --_003_A37EC4D2759E46B3856D581AC3525B1Fcernch_
> Content-Type: application/pgp-encrypted;
> 	name="PGPMIME Versions Identification"
> Content-Description: PGP/MIME Versions Identification
> Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="PGPMIME Versions Identification";
> 	size=77; creation-date="Tue, 09 Aug 2016 15:46:33 GMT";
> 	modification-date="Tue, 09 Aug 2016 15:46:33 GMT"
> Content-ID: <BA819B9B72B1154AA5469629CB120B68 at cern.ch>
> Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
> 
> VmVyc2lvbjogMQ0NCg==
> 
> --_003_A37EC4D2759E46B3856D581AC3525B1Fcernch_
> Content-Type: application/octet-stream; name="encrypted.asc"
> Content-Description: OpenPGP encrypted message.asc
> Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="encrypted.asc"; size=2688;
> 	creation-date="Tue, 09 Aug 2016 15:46:33 GMT";
> 	modification-date="Tue, 09 Aug 2016 15:46:33 GMT"
> Content-ID: <217F9582F38E094E9EEAE248370FB6B2 at cern.ch>
> Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
> 
> LS0tLS1CRUdJTiBQR1AgTUVTU0FHRS0tLS0tDQpDb21tZW50OiBHUEdUb29scyAtIGh0dHA6Ly9n
> cGd0b29scy5vcmcNCg0KaFFFTUEzZGFIQytvTm9KNUFRZi9hd3pwMFptZEp2TDRRelBCdHlFSmQ3
> NHVXVDUxanRSYXNpV0lhSDZLSnM5dg0KZVhBbkxLWFlqNWVMZ2s5QTJ3R2JCYjBSSFpUc0dZTkkw
> RWR6eEtOT1JiYnEycFpaVk1oRDVKa1MzZ1poeEFHcg0KNEFwWm9EdWVOODhkYWJxREdNZmFZVys2
> bWt0K080cFpEVHNRbkxjbEZaUDVVU0VReVg2OTREUDg2Vnl5WmdnWg0KTHUzR3JQSk1QaGdjNjFy
> a0Jhdk9yWHY5YVJ6Z21DNVBJUEk1aWIyb3JmYUJlN00yWHYxaVBsb0tvS2tmMHBFbA0KMVJSdzdZ
> S2piYkhZeWFaWjE3ZlVxSzRySy84NGdZNTRmKzlsUlBIYUp4R1hQL1JPUnMrUkdHeXZWRUhwOXJ0
> eQ0KK0Q1MXFUSWRodVVuRys3a2x5RzZoOXlLTEQvcGVON0F2aFNTZm1jeWpZVUNEQU5HY1ZrVmVM
> Yk1vUUVQL2p3Uw0KTEk5NTU5NjM3MGwzbnI5ckhHZXRLMlJ0Nmc4K2greVRRaXgvemI0UEJSdjRU
> RUVhYm9tbFFWbUJKL0lIN0RyLw0KclJwbVBGU2ZmdHVlVHk1dTdTbldEbzNDU0tvbld4ZWZLWlAz
> c0lHR3dJUEljb1p2cDFONk54aFZSdktiTUd2Zg0KTmF1blR6ck1hSFdpU2RLOHpPVDdOaWUrUThX
> MU5GbVFGckVuSUNqS1M3QVVkTS9oM0FGVzBRdEd0SHlpT3VzdA0KQWNxUlJjRHMySm1IUzNoYVJ6
> NzVXSzdCYzQ3cGVCaFkvUzkrTGhEWlNEeXdkRWtEMUFOTTNUdyt3NDZ2VGdsRg0KdnJla0gyT2xR
> Q1NBdkNxeEcvcGdLMW50bHI3eU9uUUQ4SXlQLzJIeHdiMjhXL3hZUHBWVmY3WFdJNVlqTVBEUQ0K
> TjBlRkRRTWN1WW9HTlhyOHR5aVp3OHp2UUd5R0U3dk13YTVZUGJ0aVliSXJ5c2o3c2I1UFBuVXA1
> eU12aFU4Qw0KRXVienhGQTl4b3Y4Wm9pczIvMlpLZ1NBdVgrUjIyY1gxU2wvMmRHZ29vNVZCZE9h
> bEpoS2VaOENNR0JkSzF2OA0KVkJqbFZGN3BSZ29rMUhuYTkvRWY4eFM5dVorTWhLL1Y5Y3VqdWhC
> VWxaaFVhOUFNdWJaUzh6SzFRTkwxaDNtRQ0KWW5UUEZWWWZ3SlJndWx3VkRyM1hyWVEvRnBWZDcr
> ajkwNzdBdVE3T2ozMGNpZjBUbDFkSDY2MWFCY0FFdnMwSA0KSXhTM2tocXJ5VExNYm1sT0Q5b2hE
> TFpwUnhOMUhSampNL2dpWmRYM3dmSHJTV09XYi9NNHowZkZheHAvWkxjMg0KaHdjNkNqd0pzTGFC
> TEtnd1NPSGxnSHdJWjV4elh5amtQaW1oY0l2bjB1b0JRQmJUeFlmam1tbEVwRVJrSHFwdw0KK0lD
> QW5TdjZpYU0vV3l3S0IvSVJBQUxSM1d2UFkyaUVncm16ZWNPV3VzV3ZyR3pvQW4wTmV0Zkh5bTZx
> dExvYw0KY3Zuelc3Z05rNlVaRFFHNkJxeTdKKzdBUXkyczAwa001WUpwNHpiOWFWMy9ranQrTWNi
> TjRGY3ljT0p0aGxscg0KUEdzMTFyNG05aWFQWGJEazMxM01YRE5jVHZmZEIxc2J6ZUN2VCt1MVQw
> N2Y4Sk5CN0dBc0wray9iNHBseEdIOQ0KU0ZhWVlWR1o0dTdicEVFOUl0M2pjNWZIcGF6V1pWS2VE
> UllRYXRaWG5wTTU0aGtSM214VnRKQzBrK1ZDZ0wySw0KSm5YWk1Bem5EMFJ1cHVod2NpbjdJL2Yx
> NVlmL0dYdlFLaE00a2dtaHY3NXBpVEJicHI3cVdrcDlhdXBNcWhYUA0KWjFsaEJsL2NVYjlwRS9P
> bVE0WG1DY1pGU1ArdVNzQjRZdjdtQnhFU3k5cC9WNjJ6Tnl4RVczNnNHYTV4YXBhMQ0KNzlpNFB4
> aXFZK3lQa3hpQVBlVy9LUUd0RlJwOSswWmxNUHpIbGtUOTQrTHRXNUdSNXRXZytwKzZBS2pYb1RS
> NA0KTWkrb21zREJ1RTc0aTFmRjgxNkdTT1E0WWVtditVL2d2aldYU0FhQU04MDBPY1hnRFo1RDFw
> SE1XQXdZdkd0ZA0KWTNsOUkxTVFreW84ZUt2V2MzblZrUWllUjJ5dU45aGx0QzRCTThIRFA2WmY2
> WUtyQmRCKytJZ2ZoQTV1UjVGbw0KNDFSVHVKYTFIaHNmUmhHZTdmTGNaN0NuSUs4N3N0b3FiaUlO
> U0lrOHBQTU15VXFsSnZ3MHUyVEhtN2tSclZyYg0Kb056QXpkOHk3RVZQZlZRWG5rcVNBVE9CQjNy
> U2tPQ3pkOC9NV1pMeTlmY2RIdFBMRjU3VEhmSFpCc043N2VYZw0KeVd4TGpaWUVBdGRWYk1CSmpT
> T0s0RHVJcWVMT3JoRzZSUUdvc29LOCt3cWdVZ1l0VkpUTU0rZ3FMN2dndGRPcA0KSjlUaEs4WlpE
> T1hlUlZaUnBGVHB6OG4rWUI2bUVlckY4dHhsR3cxNUZxRDd4c0c2YTV6SVFGNW9YV2lhM1BiZQ0K
> dkVwNmN3aUtYMUhrVDJQNnNYWDVHenJPRitlSmR5OXVtYjU2dENGSHNuS000bDR6bzNpM3FyVGJP
> RXozR0g3Yg0KN2tyc0h3ZDJXdDRYbGFVUytQR1RUdlVFaE1KSzg2YjhoSTUzK2YremVoZnpzcjFl
> ZGZrM3VOMHdZRUpZSXlYcw0KS2VWNWdoVUVSeVBLRVBkRmZlZjF3N2swZ004bTJXNnErKzlzelpG
> R3dTSmUyWEJVNnFkNmd3UzUxN2QzOHlNUQ0KRndsRnk5T2EvZWdzSmxNcG45V3RjeXRBVUZINGZ0
> akEwT3FBNi93OWQzcUlxYWRUa3VhTHh6RDh6Ykk3Mk16RA0KSlljVEFsTnd6VjJZUjJPMm1TaVo4
> VTQ5Vkk0RHQ4N1czY2hPQU1BSW9YdHAvMjNIYkJQdlBJTlRlMEJ2SlBMNg0KeGVpYlp1NFFpV2dj
> SDVFUVVFa2l3aUJBOFVDV1JBWW1PYk1oNEIrMlg3TThuMzNLUVl0M3cvR2dXdE1vWkNLbg0KVWgy
> VFdicUR1eHdORU9qR1BoQTdSNmtlcEtOc0Y4L004T20zd0ljNnJuMlZCb1J4NU5iMEMvK21OMmpF
> Q0Rrcg0KYXVzdWZJMUNtQjVIWnhEeEd3ZmZIZUZla0ZPVzFvdGJjeFFpeVYwVkg2dGhzbnA4K0xE
> ZnRMc2lZdlpFMUFsag0KQS9kRUpRPT0NCj16Z1hRDQotLS0tLUVORCBQR1AgTUVTU0FHRS0tLS0t
> DQo=
> 
> --_003_A37EC4D2759E46B3856D581AC3525B1Fcernch_--
>